1. Manny Ramirez 2. Carl Yastrzemski
3. Jim Rice
4. Dwight Evans
5. Rickey Henderson
6. Mike Greenwell
7. Andre Dawson
8. Fred Lynn
9. Tony Conigliaro
10. Jason Bay
11. Tom Brunansky
12. Trot Nixon
13. Troy O’Leary
14. JD Drew
15. Johnny Damon
16. Bernie Carbo
17. Jose Canseco
18. Ellis Burks
19. Tony Armas
20. Don Baylor
21. Tommy Harper
22. Jacoby Ellsbury
23. Dave Henderson
24. Carl Everett
25. Coco Crisp
26. Phil Plantier
27. Kevin Romine
28. Willie McGee
29. Dante Bichette
30. Darren Lewis
31. Gabe Kapler
32. Otis Nixon
33. Orlando Merced
34. Dave Roberts
35. Mark Whiten
36. Wes Chamberlain
Orlando Merced didn't even have a hit with us... so I take it this is best outfielders "who at one time played for the Red Sox"? But then shouldn't Willie McGee be way above Kevin Romine? Lists make my head explode:)
ReplyDeleteBig Problems with this list. If you are talking best outfielder in his career that happened to set foot in the Sox outfield Rickey has to go first over Manny and any other.
ReplyDeleteIf the list is best career as a Sox outfielder you cannot have Bay as high after only 1.5 years and there is no way on the planet you should have Damon under Drew.
If the list is best year as a SOx outfielder than MVP Lynn should be much higher, as with Damon, and Rickey should be near the bottom.
What were you getting at anyway? I agree with Jere.
Hey, it's my list. :)
ReplyDeleteIt's best Red Sox outfielders, as a Red Sox, with special consideration to career accomplishments. So, Rickey can't beat out players with real Red Sox careers, but can squeek by just about everyone else. Feel free to offer your own lists.