Saturday, March 6, 2010

Can I Quote You on That?

Losing clubs bicker, and you think maybe if they pulled together they would win. No. That’s not it. If they won, they would pull together. – Jim Bouton

Ahh. The annual argument of clubhouse chemistry. Which come first…the chicken or the egg? Is life like a Disney movie? If everyone is having fun, will it make them winners? I think I’m with Mr. Bouton on this one. In baseball, it just doesn’t matter.

Baseball is rather unlike other sports in that it really is a collection of individuals, as opposed to a team. Maybe defensively, there’s some give and take between teammates. Who’s covering what when? How much should one player shade to the left if another player is shading to the right? But, on offense, it’s all about the individual. If a player gets his three hits every time at bat, it doesn’t matter what’s going on around him. He just needs to play his game. If everyone is playing their game, the team is winning, and everyone is happy. If everyone isn’t playing their game, and slumping, than they’re not winning, and nobody is happy.

I’m reminded of Darryl Strawberry. I don’t remember if it was in 1998, or 1999, but he was upset about his playing time. He thought he should be playing more than he was. It’s that sort of attitude that creates bad clubhouse chemistry. But, as Strawberry himself pointed out, the team was winning. How could he complain about his playing time if the team was on a roll? So, he kept his mouth, mostly, shut. Isn’t that exactly what Bouton was talking about? The team was winning, so they pulled together. Now, if the Yankees were in last place, I bet you Strawberry would be telling everyone he could see that he should be playing more. Losing clubs bicker.

I think it’s pretty clear that winning leads to everything else. Why can Jeter inspire his teammates to play well? Because the team is winning. Why was Milton Bradley such trouble in Chicago? Because the Cubs stunk. Players do what they do, and teams win or lose. No rah-rah cheers will change that. No Grumbling will change it.

Which is why Manny should still be in a Boston uniform.



  1. Adam_The_Yankee_FanMarch 8, 2010 at 12:18 PM

    3 words of advice:

    Let him go.

  2. But, if the Sox were leading their division by 15 games at thetime, he's probably still on the team.

  3. Adam_the_Yankee_FanMarch 9, 2010 at 8:07 AM

    Jeter and Arod are buds again. There was an article in one of the NY papers which made a big deal of the two going to and from games in the same car.

    Are they better bacause of winning, or did they win because they were better?

    I know what you think, and I bet if you asked Billy Martin and Reggie they would agree with you. You can hate your teamates and still win.

    Would it make you feel better if they got Nomar to come back? He is available.

  4. Getting Nomar back would certainly be cool.

    And, yes, it's interesting that Jeter and ARod became friends again AFTER winning.


What people are reading this week